• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar

FromThePage Blog

Crowdsourcing, transcription and indexing for libraries and archives

  • Home
  • Interviews
  • crowdsourcing
  • how-to
  • Back to FromThePage
  • Collections

Push vs Pull Crowdsourcing

May 4, 2022 By Sara Brumfield

Maybe you’re running a crowdsourcing project because your boss thought it would be a good idea.  Maybe your outreach person came to you with the idea.  Maybe you heard about it at a conference and love the idea of engaging the public with your documents in the deep way transcription allows.  I call these “push” transcription projects.

Or…  maybe you’re Billie and Taneya.  You’re passionate genealogists who are active in all sorts of organizations and projects in Tennessee -- TennesseeGenWeb, USGenWeb, and the Nashville Chapter of the Afro-American Historical & Genealogical Society.  You pulled together a group of volunteer genealogists to work with historian Camille Westmont on the records of convict labor at the Lone Rock Stockade.  You started your own FromThePage project indexing names from historical Tennessee newspapers.  And then you went to the Tennessee State Archives and said, “We really want to do this with your records.”

Or maybe you’re a passionate whaling history nerd who transcribed ships’ logs from the Nantucket Historical Society and thought “hey, I know my local library has ships’ logs in their special collections” and went to the small but mighty East Hampton Public Library and said “look at this!  We should do this too!”*  (*I don’t know exactly what he said, I just know Andrea told me that’s how they got to FromThePage.)

I think these stories are amazing.  You should sit up and take notice when someone like Billie or Taneya comes to you, because that means you have passionate volunteers who are ready and willing to work with you on your material.  Sure, you could post material on FromThePage and some volunteers will find it and, if you’re supportive and helpful, stay engaged and keep working. But starting with a core of super passionate local or interested volunteers means you'll have much higher engagement.  They’ll care a lot more about your material. They’ll organize transcribathons and help you promote the ones you organize.  They’ll talk about your project -- and organization -- on local media.  

You might even find yourself in the situation Sonya Coleman and the team at the Library of Virginia is in.  Their digitization program is driven, in part, by the needs of the transcribers.  Sonya calls it “feeding the beast” because LVA has created this great transcription program and now they have a commitment to keep it going.  So they keep digitizing material for volunteers to work on.

I think of this as “pull” transcription projects.  You’re not pushing material onto your transcribers, but rather your transcribers are merrily pulling you & your institution to where they’d like you to be.  It’s like surfing -- if you can catch the wave and balance on it, it’s amazing.  If you can’t, you’ll miss the wave.

Want to find out if your materials fall under push or pull transcription projects? Reserve a call with Ben and Sara.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: crowdsourcing

Primary Sidebar

What’s Trending on The FromThePage Blog

  • Classifying the Mistakes We Make When We Transcribe
  • Archives as an Antidote for ChatGPT
  • Start Reading Old Handwriting: Some Recommended Books
  • How Do I Read Old Handwriting?
  • An Interview with Dr. Camille Westmont of Sewanee:…
  • Interview: Sonya Coleman on Transcribing for the…

Recent Client Interviews

An Interview with NC State University Libraries

An Interview with Richard Gilreath of the Texas State Library and Archives Commission

An Interview with Julanne Neal of the Queensland State Archives

An Interview with Andrea Meyer of East Hampton Public Library

An Interview with Keith Mitchell of The National Archives (UK)

Read More

artificial intelligence crowdsourcing features fromthepage projects handwriting history iiif indexing Indianapolis Indianapolis Children's Museum interview Jennifer Noffze machine learning metadata ocr paleography podcast Ryan White spreadsheet transcription transcription transcription software
Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | About Us | Contact Us

Copyright © 2023 · FromThePage.com